About Our Firm

Experienced Family Law, Criminal Defense, and Estate Planning Attorneys

The Law Office of Melissa Winkler-York, LLC was founded in Indianapolis in 2009 with one attorney and one staff member. Since then, the firm has grown to five attorneys and seven full-time staff members serving clients throughout Indianapolis and central Indiana in family law, criminal defense, and estate planning matters.

How We Work

Legal matters are rarely simple, and they are often stressful. Our goal is to make the process clearer and more manageable from the very beginning. We take the time to understand your situation, explain your options in plain language, and outline realistic next steps.

We believe in honest advice. That means we will tell you what is possible, what is likely, and what may not be worth pursuing. We focus on practical solutions and preparation rather than unnecessary conflict. Our team works efficiently, communicates directly, and keeps you informed as your case moves forward.

Whether you are facing a family law dispute, criminal charge, or planning for the future, you can expect thoughtful guidance, careful preparation, and steady representation every step of the way.

What to Expect During the Intake Process

Our initial consultations are free. To get started, complete our intake form. The information you provide allows us to conduct an initial review of your matter before scheduling a consultation.

After reviewing your information, a member of our team will follow up to discuss next steps and schedule a meeting if appropriate. During your consultation, we will listen carefully, answer your questions, and outline realistic options moving forward.

Our goal is to make the first step clear, organized, and as stress-free as possible.


Professional Recognition

Attorneys at our firm have been recognized by Super Lawyers and Rising Stars and are Lead Counsel Verified.

Melissa Winkler-York Super Lawyers recognition Tiffany McCoy Rising Stars recognition Lead Counsel Verified
Attorney and Owner Melissa Winkler-York

Melissa Winkler-York

Melissa opened her law practice in 2009 after working as an associate attorney at another law firm for almost five years. She was admitted to the Indiana Bar in the fall of 2004, having earned her J.D. at the Indiana University School of Law at Indianapolis (now called the Robert H. McKinney School of Law). She attended Purdue University and earned her B.A. in 2000.

Senior Associate Attorney Elisha Comer

Elisha Comer

Elisha began working as an associate attorney for The Law Office of Melissa Winkler-York, LLC in April 2018. She was admitted to the Indiana Bar in the fall of 2011 and has worked as a child support prosecutor in Hamilton County, as a DCS attorney in Marion County, and in private practice.

Attorney Justin Smith

Justin Smith

Justin began working as an associate attorney for The Law Office of Melissa Winkler-York, LLC in October 2022. He attended the Robert H. McKinney School of Law and graduated in May 2022. Prior to being admitted to the bar, he was a certified legal intern at The Law Office of Melissa Winkler-York, LLC.

Attorney Tiffany McCoy

Tiffany McCoy

Tiffany began working as an associate attorney for The Law Office of Melissa Winkler-York, LLC in April 2024. Prior to working for Melissa, Tiffany was a Deputy Attorney General at the Office of the Indiana Attorney General, where she focused on criminal appeals. She later turned to private practice, where she focused on criminal and family law. Tiffany obtained her law degree from Valparaiso University Law School, where she was an honors program scholar and graduated magna cum laude.

Attoreny Nicholas Andre

Nicholas Andre

Nick began working as an associate attorney for The Law Office of Melissa Winkler-York, LLC in July 2024. Prior to that, he worked for the Department of Child Services and in private practice. Nick attended the Robert H. McKinney School of Law and graduated in 2019. He was admitted to the Indiana Bar the same year.